What it adds beyond the basics
Every editor here does layers, masks, raw files, non-destructive edits and batch processing, so none of those earn a point. What is left is what separates them: opening and saving layered Photoshop files, generative fill, selecting a subject by itself, upscaling, removing a background, working in CMYK for print, pressure from a tablet, and a template library.
Opens and saves layered Photoshop files5.9 pts
✓Adobe Photoshop✓GIMP✓Photopea✕Affinity
Generative fill and expand4.9 pts
✓Adobe Photoshop✓Affinity✓Photopea✕GIMP
Generates images from a prompt4.2 pts
✓Adobe Photoshop✓Affinity✕GIMP✕Photopea
Selects a subject or sky by itself4.2 pts
✓Adobe Photoshop✓Affinity✓Photopea✕GIMP
AI image editing (erase, relight)3.2 pts
✓Adobe Photoshop✓Affinity✓Photopea✕GIMP
One-action background removal3.2 pts
✓Adobe Photoshop✓Affinity✓Photopea✕GIMP
AI upscaling3.1 pts
✓Adobe Photoshop✓Affinity✕GIMP✕Photopea
Works in CMYK for print3.1 pts
✓Adobe Photoshop✓Affinity✓Photopea✕GIMP
Pressure sensitivity from a tablet or stylus1.8 pts
✓Affinity✓GIMP✕Photopea
Template library1.4 pts
✓Adobe Photoshop✓Photopea✕GIMP
Highest here Adobe Photoshop 9.8 · lowest GIMP 2.2 out of 10